| icon | info |
|---|---|
 | Big Debut! Complete your first match |
 | I Hope The Ref Didn't See That Hit an opponent with a steel chair |
 | I'm Just a Spectator Watch 5 AI vs. AI battles |
 | Can't win 'em All Lose 10 matches |
 | Learn the Ropes, Kid Complete the tutorial in Story Mode |
 | I Don't Need The Ring! Win a falls count anywhere match outside the ring |
 | I Don't Think So, Brother! Win a match after triggering a Second Wind |
 | Nowhere To Run Win a cage match inside the "Chain Link" cage |
 | Unforgiving Steel Win a cage match inside the "Big Blue" cage |
 | That's Why They Call It High Risk Miss an attack from the top of the cage |
 | Innovator of Violence Win a match as Tommy Dreamer |
 | Alwayz Ready Win a match as Matt Cardona |
 | Whipped Into Shape Win a match as Stevie Richards in the SRF Arena |
 | The Real Star of the Show Win a match as Johnny Retro |
 | SPLX King Win a match as Jeff Cobb |
 | National Treasure Win a match as Nick Aldis |
 | The Most Professional Wrestler Win a match as Brian Myers |
 | What Is Going On Here? Win a match as Warhorse in Warhorse's Hell Arena |
 | Hurrah! Another Trophy! Win a match as Zack Sabre Jr. by submission |
 | Boom Boom! Win a match as Colt Cabana |
 | Kickin' it Old School Win a match as Nikita Koloff in the NWA 70 Arena |
 | Generation Clash Win a match as Nick Aldis against Austin Idol in the NWA Power arena |
 | The Real World's Champion Complete 10 Pounds of Gold |
 | Bonesaw is Ready! Defeat your opponent within 3 minutes inside a steel cage |
 | We're Takin' Over! Win a 6-man tag team match as the Blue World Order |
 | What a Rush! Win a Tag Team match as Hawk & Animal |
 | Major Marks Win a Tag match as Cardona & Myers in the STOMP In Paradise Arena |
 | 5 Time, 5 Time, 5 Time Complete 10 Pounds of Gold with 5 different wrestlers |
 | I'll Take 'em Both, I'm Hardcore Win a 3-way match with Tommy Dreamer in the Ballroom |
 | Established Talent Win 20 matches |
 | Main Eventer Win 50 matches |
 | And Then There Was One Win a 4-way elimination match |
 | No One Gets Up From That Land 3 finishing moves in one match |
 | Killin' the Biz Kick out of an opponent's finishing move |
 | And Still Successfully defend a championship in Exhibition Mode |
 | The Best-ler, Better Than All the Rest-ler Complete chapter 3 of Story Mode |
 | I Have Sailed the World, Beheld Its Wonders Win a match in every arena |
 | Skinning the Cat Win a Retro Rumble |
 | Retromania World Champion Earn all other achievements |
 | Ultimate Finesser Win a match as Chris Bey |
 | Six Pack Win a match as James Storm after taunting 6 times |
 | Man Who Stole the Urn Win a match as Mr. Hughes |
 | One More For The Good Guys Complete Story Mode as a face |
 | By Any Means Necessary Complete Story Mode as a tweener |
 | They Say Winners Never Cheat? Well, Cheaters Never Lose. Complete Story Mode as a heel |
 | Why Do They Keep One of Those Under The Ring? |
 | Dance the Neon Noir With Me Win 13 matches in Warhorse's Hell Arena |
 | Reign of Terror In Versus Mode, defend a championship 10 times in a row |
 | Hall Of Famer Win your 100th match |
